PreacherRhetorica
  • Home and to sermons
    • Year B frontispiece >
      • Proper 5B
      • Seventh of Easter
      • Sixth of Easter
      • Fifth of Easter
      • Fourth of Easter homily
      • Third of Easter
      • Second of Easter
      • Easter Day
      • Maundy Thursday
      • Palm Sunday
      • Lent 5
      • Next Before Lent
      • Presentation (Epiphany 4)
      • Third of Epiphany
      • Second of Epiphany
      • Epiphany (2)
      • Epiphany
      • Holy Innocents
      • Christmas
      • The Reign of Christ (Proper 29B)
      • Christ the King (Proper 29B)
      • Proper 28B (2nd Bf Advent)
      • 3rd Bf Advent (CofE)
      • Proper 27B
      • All Saints Sunday
      • Proper 26B
      • Proper 25B
      • Simon and Jude
      • Proper 24B
      • Proper 23B
      • Proper 22B
      • Proper 22B homily
      • Proper 21B
      • Proper 20B
      • Proper 19B
      • Proper 18B sermon
      • Proper 18B performance poem
      • Proper 17B
      • Proper 16B
      • Proper 15B
      • Proper 14B
      • Proper 13B
      • Proper 12B
      • Mary Magdalene homily
      • Proper 11B
      • Proper 10B
      • Proper 9B homily
      • Proper 8B
      • Birth of John the Baptist
      • Proper 7B homily
      • Proper 6B
      • Trinity Sunday
      • Pentecost
      • Lent 4 Mothering Sunday
      • Lent 3
      • Lent 2
      • Lent 1
      • 2nd Before Lent
      • 3rd Before Lent
      • 2nd of Christmas B homily
      • Christmas Day
      • Advent 4B
      • Advent 3B
      • Advent 2B
      • Advent 1B homily
      • Year A frontispiece >
        • Proper 28A (2 Bf Advent)
        • Proper 27A (3 Bf Advent)
        • Proper 26A (4 Bf Advent)
        • Proper 25A Last after Trinity
        • Proper 24A
        • Proper 23A
        • Proper 22A
        • Proper 21A
        • St Matthew
        • Proper 20A
        • Proper 19A
        • Proper 18A
        • Proper 17A
        • Proper 16A
        • Proper 15A
        • Proper 14A
        • Proper 13A
        • Proper 12A
        • Proper 11A
        • Proper 10A
        • Proper 9A
        • Proper 8A
        • Proper 7A
        • Trinity Sunday (Homily)
        • Pentecost
        • Seventh of Easter (Sunday after Ascension)
        • Sixth of Easter
        • Fifth of Easter
        • Fourth of Easter
        • Third of Easter
        • Second of Easter
        • Easter (Poem)
        • Maundy Thursday
        • Palm Sunday
        • Lent 5
        • Lent 4
        • Lent 3
        • Lent 2
        • Lent 1
        • Next Bf Lent (Epiphany last)
        • 2 Bf Lent (Proper 3)
        • Epiphany 7 (RCL)
        • Epiphany 6 (3 Bf Lent)
        • Epiphany 5 (4 Bf Lent)
        • Presentation of Christ
        • Epiphany 3
        • Epiphany 2
        • Baptism of Christ (Epiphany 1)
        • The Epiphany
        • Second Sunday of Christmas
        • First Sunday of Christmas
        • Christmas Day
        • Advent 4A
        • Advent 3A
        • Advent 2A
        • Advent 1A
        • Christ the King Yr A (2)
        • Christ the King Yr A
        • Remembrance Sunday
        • All Saints' Sunday
        • Harvest Homily
        • Harvest
        • Admission of Pastoral Workers
        • Saint Thomas homily
        • Corpus Christi
        • Trinity Sunday
        • Pentecost
        • Pentecost: another example
        • Year C frontispiece >
          • Christ the King (Next bf Advent)
          • Proper 28C (2nd bf Advent)
          • Proper 27C (3rd bf Advent)
          • Proper 26C (4th bf Advent)
          • Proper 25C (Last after Trinity)
          • Proper 24C
          • Proper 23C
          • Proper 22C
          • St Michael & All Angels (homily)
          • Proper 21C
          • Proper 20C
          • Proper 19C (story sermon)
          • Proper 18C
          • Proper 17C
          • Proper 16C
          • Proper 15C
          • Proper 14C
          • Proper 13C
          • Proper 12C
          • Proper 11C
          • Proper 10C
          • Proper 9C
          • Proper 8C
          • Proper 7C
          • Proper 6C performance poem
          • Proper 5C
          • Proper 4C
          • Trinity
          • Pentecost homily
          • Seventh of Easter
          • Ascension Day
          • Sixth of Easter
          • Fifth of Easter
          • Fourth of Easter
          • Third of Easter
          • Second of Easter
          • Easter homily
          • Easter (story sermon)
          • Maundy Thursday
          • Palm Sunday
          • Lent 5C
          • Mothering Sunday
          • Lent 4C homily
          • Lent 3C (story sermon)
          • Lent 2C
          • Lent 1C
          • Ash Wednesday homily
          • Next Bf Lent/Last of Epiphany
          • Epiphany 4 (RCL)
          • Second Before Lent
          • Presentation of Christ
          • Fourth of Epiphany
          • Third of Epiphany
          • Baptism of Christ
          • The Epiphany
          • First of Christmas homily
          • Christmas Day homily
          • Christmas Day
          • Advent 4C
          • Advent 3C
          • Advent 2C
          • Advent 1C
        • Non-lectionary sermons >
          • Plough Sunday
          • Advent and Christmas ideas
          • Christmas Day homily
          • A Christmas Tale
          • Remembrance 2013
          • Remembrance Sunday
          • Harvest homily 2
          • Harvest
          • Harvest homily
          • Harvest Water
          • New Pastoral Ministry
        • Ascension
  • Homiletics
    • A Definition of Preaching
    • Speaking locally
    • Notes from a masterclass
    • Design analysis 1
    • Design analysis 2
    • Encouraging feedback
    • Preaching in an amnesic society
    • The Aldi bag syndrome
    • Blog
  • Disciplecraft
  • Recommended
    • Preaching Fools
  • Second of Epiphany

Where there's muck
A story sermon for Lent 3C
Luke 13.1-9 The sermon on which this commentary is based is here.

Picture
This sermon does employ, briefly, direct theological analysis but not
until a narrative of George’s life has been given in some detail. The story
serves as a commentary to this theological analysis – the very serious issue that Jesus discusses and his call for repentance is framed within a village tale. That tale aims to be an empathetic parallel that allows Jesus’ words to be heard as down-to-earth good news.
 
Why use a story? Here is the preacher’s reasoning behind the method:
 
Jesus often used stories. The story (parable) the Lucan passage  concludes with is used here as a motif for the story sermon. This is a story deliberately associated with a story told by Jesus the storyteller. That deliberation asks for a response by the very fact of its association. The hearer must decide whether this is a fitting story to be a commentary on a
Jesus story.
 
Stories shape experience. The Gospel writers shaped their accounts of Jesus’ actions and words in a story form. Using a story to interpret that  greater story allows their shaping to in turn shape what the preacher says. This isn’t to claim that this is the definitive way of approaching the Gospel texts, but only that form as well as content offers a way of getting closer to Christ.

Stories engage. The narrative form draws the hearer into the account. Wanting to know ‘how it turns out’ keeps the hearer with the speaker. The question in the story of George is whether he could make something good of what others thought a lonely and derided life? The implication from the start is that there’s much more to George than most people saw, but the hearer wants to be reassured that such is the case.
 
Stories appeal because they use familiar forms. Stories employ everyday language and thought forms that subvert complexities of language and ideas. Stories by their very ordinariness can examine issues that complex language and conceptual approaches sometimes obscure. In this case the Gospel passage starts with Jesus in conversation, and then moves to him as a storyteller – this familiar and vernacular style is then taken up in the story sermon. Jesus is  dealing with profound issues about suffering and making a challenging and unequivocal statement about evil, yet always in a common language form. In the story sermon the use of a common saying – ‘where there’s muck there’s money’ –  underscores such usage.
 
Stories make for directness and applicability. In the conversation and parable Jesus uses sharp words. His expression is neither qualified nor elaborated. Its’ very directness is a key aspect of its power to communicate. Using a story form allows a continuation of that sharpness. The words used to describe how George is treated replicate Jesus’ directness. The story sermon ends by a question just as directly asked of the hearer.
 
Stories are memorable. Narratives ‘live’ in people’s minds in a way more conceptual expression does not. Remembering plot, characterisation, development of ideas, and many other aspects of things said or read is all more
readily done within in a narrative framework. As the memory masters of old knew, and as contemporary situational comedians exemplify, much more can be remembered if it is encapsulated in a story. Add aphorisms that are memorable  or already well known and hearers will remember with very little encouragement from the speaker. This is just the kind of response the expression ‘where there’s muck there’s money’ is aiming at in the story sermon. Its turning into‘where there was muck there was mercy’ seeks to make a theological point just as memorable.

Stories provoke imaginative participation. The parable of the fig tree in the vineyard provides a good example. Jesus uses very few words but nevertheless it is easy to feel the owners indignation and the gardeners clever  response; it is easy also to ‘see’ the green but fruitless tree in contrast to  the fruiting vines so near to it; and finally the gardener’s wisdom asks for a response but that it is given is left entirely in the hearer’s mind. The story sermon in a similar way paints several scenes and asks the hearer to fill-in the details. What the hearer ‘sees’ is a vital part of the story but it isn’t proscribed by the storyteller. Much is left for the hearer to complete in his or her imagination.
 
Stories use our emotions. The hearers of a story are enabled to add their own emotional response without necessarily disclosing it to anyone else. This gives a safe space in which hearers are freed to utilize their own
emotions. Because this use of emotions is largely an interior event in the person’s mind a wide-range of varying responses are possible. For example, and as is suggested in the sermon, the line about manure in the parable might be read humorously. Is Jesus saying that mulching the fig tree – the central and obviously dominating presence in the vineyard of much smaller plant – is a metaphor for those prominent in the faith that are evidently not fruiting as they should? Perhaps covering them in muck might prompt them to produce good fruit! Could this be Jesus making a joke at the expense of the religious establishment? Whether it is or not, the way manure and its’ associated terms are used both for humour and for insult is picked up in the story sermon. Without being vulgar, the story sermon attempts to employ colloquial humour and
insult in a way that connects with ordinary experience in an insightful way. 
 
It remains for the hearers to decide whether the story of George connects their thoughts with the words of Jesus.  
 
‘Who sinned, they said, this man or his parents? But the question is senseless. It applied no more to George than it does to you. In his life where there was muck there was mercy. And that's always the way with God - muck and mercy. Live it or perish.’ 

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.